25 Comments
User's avatar
sandracwyatt's avatar

Love this Alan!! missing Robbie, this was a fun list to go through! Myself and several family members watch “the last waltz about 3 times a year, since it came out on Video back in the day. Miss them all!!

Sharon Thomason's avatar

What a great choice of tunes! I imagine it was really hard to narrow it down to ten!

Alan Paul's avatar

Thanks. Yeah. Honestly don’t remember exactly how we came up with this, but Warren and I discussed it a lot. Further on up the road obviously only because it was for Guitar World. 

lou J's avatar

I love Warren’s description of the band-attuned artistry. They were truly magical. And I thank you for this write up.

Anthony B. Creamer III's avatar

Thanks for your list, Alan. I look forward to the one you create to highlight Robbie's compositions. You might start with Twilight and many of the songs on his solo records.

Rich Paddock's avatar

Nice try. It’s a rich catalog. I won’t quibble.

Alan Paul's avatar

Yeah. all such lists must be taken with a grain of salt. What I was doing here was looking for songs that would allow us to write about different aspects of Robbie's playing, and Warren really did make a lot of the choices.

Jim Finn's avatar

Still really love Robbie Robertson (1987 with U2)

Avery Burns's avatar

How did the time fly so quickly? You need more room for so MANY good songs. I have accidentally got old. Thanks for your work. It means something to a sentimental nobody.

The sum of the nobodies build legends.

Alan Paul's avatar

Thank you. Nobody is a nobody.

PRAY WITHOUT CEASING's avatar

What's so great about Further on up the road, is Clapton's guitar strap coming undone and Eric calling out to him, "Robbie"! And Robertson just jumping right in with a hot lick until Clapton gets resituated, without missing a beat - Two total professionals.

Dave Connell's avatar

Amazing list and commentary. There could obviously be another 10 and another 10, and another... Maybe not quite a top 10, but likely in the second 10 for me would be "Broken Arrow." I was reminded how great that song was last Sunday when Dead and Co. played it with Graham Lesh. John Mayer sang it beautifully -- very much right in his wheelhouse.

Peggy R.'s avatar

Thanks what a great post!! So much fun to listen to the songs 👏👏

lou J's avatar

I forwarded your post to a friend, Garth, former professional musician who toured with Pearl Jam, is a big fan of The Band, named his kids after the other members. he swooned in response, sent me a pic of Robbie’s memoir which he had just started reading. Thanks for nudging some friends to converge.

Alan Paul's avatar

I LOVE THIS. Thank you. Tell Garth to subscribe!

lou J's avatar

Glad it made you feel good. Well, I sent him the post, so that’s a nudge in that direction , but I will leave it up to him!

Jared Wolfsen's avatar

Love Robbie! Both he and Jerry passed on my birthday. List is great but I appreciate a lot of his solo stuff and those first two albums are tops in my book. I would add Broken Arrow, Soap Box Preacher and Somewhere Down That Crazy River to the list. Whenever I cover Soap Box Preacher on solo guitar, people are always commenting on what a great song it is.

Sean Greeley's avatar

Broken Arrow from his 1987 solo album is an A+ song as well.

Kid Charlemagne's avatar

To think that thirty years ago today August 8th, I was at Summerstage in Central Park watching Ratdog open for The Band enjoying the beautiful weather and fantastic music, mail order sent in and thinking about fall tour. And then the next morning the news broke….

Donald Thieme's avatar

Dry Your Eyes?

Donald Thieme's avatar

These are great songs, mostly by the Band. I am not sure this list captures the best of Robbie as guitarist and several are songs written mostly by other members of the Band. Robbie did some great work producing for others. I would definitely have put "Broken Arrow" on here.